|
MGG Pillai Commentary Search
|
|
| Page 1 << Previous || Next >>
|
Found 98 matches for Johore Bahru
| |
| 2006-04-14 | The crooked bridge and cultural enmity
|
| 2006-02-27 | Would there be another 'May 13'?
|
| 2006-02-01 | Singapore-Malaysia relations Rightly, Malaysia insisted on a share of that profits. Another public
relations barrage attacked Malaysia for asking a share of the
profits. But Singapore is on the defensive. It knows it cannot look
Malaysia in the eye. There is talk of invading Malaysia. The crooked
bridge is not as fanciful or odd as it seems. This would prevent a
Singapore army from ever invading Malaysia. They do not have the
ingenuity of the Japanese army, who finding the Australian sappers
had bombed the causeway, crossed into the island from Johore Bahru by
cross the channel on bicycles with propellers. The British were sure
the Japanese would attack the island in conventional ways, had all
its heavy guns trained outside, when the Japanese army caught them
unawares from behind.
|
| 2006-01-29 | Mr C.V. Devan Nair and the Malayalis He was the son of I.V.K. Nair, from Palghat, who had come to Malaysia
in 1910, and was brought to the then Federated Malay States. He
appointed agents later in all districts. That is how Inspector P.C.
Joseph. from Alwaye, and my father, from Thalavady, came to Malaysia.
It was to Inspector Joseph's house in Johore Bahru I was taken after
I was born at the General Hospital in Johore Bahru in 1939. James
Puthucheary, who joined the Indian National Army in his twenties, was
in detention with Mr Nair, when his father in 1956 died. He was among the
small band of Malayalis who provided the PAP with the left
intellectual framework, for which they were exiled in old age. Mr
Puthucheary studied law, died a rich corporate lawyer in Malaysia,
believed to the end he had failed. He said to me he would title his
autobiography, which he never wrote mainly because of the stroke that
ravaged his last days, "The Autobiography of a Failure." He was
banned for almost 25 years from the island, lifted after his friend's
wife died in Singapore, he wanted to attend the funeral, and just
before he did. As an aside, I was put on restricted entry into
Singapore in 1971, and permanently banned in 1991. But as I told an
Italian journalist, who put the quote in his book, "I have already
done my shopping."
|
| 2006-01-27 | The National Front's ambivalence towards women The UMNO General Assembly had seriously argued banning those who left
UMNO from returning, aimed at preventing the former deputy president
and former Malaysian deputy prime minister, Dato' Seri Anwar Ibrahim
for returning to UMNO, but the resolution was hastily withdrawn when
it was discovered that three UMNO presidents, two alive, would have
been banned. The prime miniser, Pak Lah, when he was foreign
minister, had gone to Johore Bahru for the byelection in which Dato'
Shahrir Samad, now of the Backbenchers' Club, had stood as an
independent against the UMNO Baru candidate, and he was supported by
the old UMNO hands who disagreed with the new UMNO. Pak Lah had
joined the new UMNO crowd going to file nomination papers. He said he
did not know what to do when he met Dato' Shahrir Samad pushing the
Tengku in a wheelchair, and followed by thousands waving the UMNO
flag. The Tengku and Tun Hussein Onn remained loyal to the UMNO which
had been declared illegal, and refused to join the new entity. The
only difference between the two UMNO flags is that the insigna is
smaller on the new UMNO.
|
| 2006-01-25 | UMNO got rid off the Tengku with a riot, but did not think through its plan afterwords When Tun Mahathir came acalling on the Tengku in hospital on his
terminal illness, I, who had gone to see him before Tun Mahathir, was
asked to say. There was a tug-of-war of sorts between Tun Mahathir's
security detail and the Tengku. He finally made me sit on the bed
beside him. So when Tun Mahathir came in, I was also in the room. The
Tengku had known me since the early 1950s, when as president of UMNO
he shifted to Johore Bahru, and stayed near the edge of the Wadi
Hana area where I stayed. When my father died in 1963, he was
already prime minister and I did not inform him. When I returned to
Reuters in Singapore from leave after the funeral to the night shift,
I found the Tengku there. He told me to see him for breakfast at the
Hotel Adephi, now no more. "M.A.G. Pillai was the Tengku's friend,
not the prime minister's." giving me a wigging as only he could. He
was in Saudi Arabia when my mother died in 1978, so I sent him a
cable, and two of his personal staff turned up before the cremation.
He used to say he was the happiest prime minister in the world
because "he had as his deputy, Tun Razak". Tun Razak's premiership
was spoiled for this reason. But little did he know, until it was too
late, that Tun Razak was plotting against him. Tun Mahathir and the
future deputy prime minister, Tan Sri Musa Hitam, were some of the
plotters.
|
| 2006-01-04 | The National Front is in trouble, as always, but it had better watch out
|
| 2005-12-21 | The National Front is confused The rebels against British rule in Malaya came from the titled: Dato'
Bahaman, Mat Kilau, Maharaja Lela, Dato' Sagor were on the royal
court. They failed because they could not get the people on their
side in fighting the British, who hanged most of them. Our officials
did not bother until Mat Kilau was found to be alive. There were
intense discussions in the 20th century whether he ought to be given
a dato'ship. I knew his son-in-law and daughter, and have stayed with
them when I was in the capital he was Malaysian ambassador. He later
became an official at the Organisation of Islamic Conference when
Tengku Abul Rahman, Malaysia's first prime minister, was secretary-
general. But until Mat Kilau was found alive, the Malaysian people,
if ever, did not know the connection. Both are dead now, his widow
died in a car crash. The people will not move unless led. UMNO was
founded in the Istana in Johore Bahru, Dato' Sir Onn bin Jaffar its
founding president, was a cousin of the sultan, and mentri besar of
Johore. (His mother's sister, both Circassions from Turkey, was the
wife of Sultan Abubakar, grandfather of the present Sultan.) Many of
the earlier leaders of UMNO were from the palace. It is only the last
two presidents, Tun Mahathir Mohamed and Dato' Seri Abdullah Ahmad
Badawi, were not from the aristocratic class, although Tun Mahathir's
mother was from the Kedah royal court.
|
| 2005-12-13 | The Pengkalen Pasir byelection is faulty because of Malay Dominance More important, the average non-Malay can be persuaded, even if that
is now more difficult - a Chinese voter, a former MCA executive in
Pengkalen Pasir, who had moved to Kuala Lumpur in the last six months
to take over his father's business, agreed to go back to vote only if
he was given $1,000, air fare, and hotel and living expenses for
three days in Pengkalen Pasir - but a Malay does not automatically
vote for the National Front if he is brought to vote. And he is
likely to complain if someone votes on his behalf. The National Front
in the constituency is angry that he is superseded by the
organisation in the centre, and is likely to join in the chorus of
nay-sayers. The National Front in the centre organises a campaign
that often results in more people than they are voters into the
constituency, and what it says and does is often not useful in the
campaign, but the voter in Johore Bahru or Kedah is told of the
National Front's supposed efficient in Kelantan, but is ignored by
voters in the Kelantan constituency.
|
| 2005-12-12 | In multiracial Malaysia, the non-Malay looks to Malay leaders in the National Front as more credible than their own! The elections in Pengkalen Pasir was between UMNO and PAS, and UMNO
was represented by the National Front. It has fine tuned the art of
putting down the non-Malay over the years, and does so every day but
Election day. Malaysians are told that the non-Malay must be put down
in favour of the Malay. The reason is Malay Dominance and the New
Economic Policy. I agreed with the policy when it first started, and
its progenitors agreed at the time it could go wrong but the Malay
would overcome their setbacks and would benefit from the government
help. The Malay had been given a raw deal by the British, because the
immigrant races - the Chinese and Indians - were more energetic, and
were favoured. The British trained Malays to be like them, in the
early years of the 20th century. The Malay College in Kuala Kangsar
was modelled on Eton in the United Kingdom. Those who went to Malay
Schools had to be educated in remove class before they could go
English schools. On independence in 1957, this social structure was
put in effect. The great debates in Parliament in the late 1950s were
by political party leaders of all political parties, the Alliance and
the opposition, Malay and non-Malay. And which is how I ended up at
the English College in Johore Bahru and those in school at that time
was Tan Sri Mohamed Rahmat, my class mate, and the former deputy
prime minister, Tan Sri Musa Hitam, as my head prefect; others who
were in school included Dato' Dominic Puthucheary, the former MCA
president Tan Sri Lee San Choon. It would not happen now.
|
| 2005-12-01 | The Pengkalen Pasir byelection is not to benefit the constituency, but to prove a point UMNO has suggested PAS should resign if it lost Pengkalen Pasir next
week. But that has been modified later by saying that PAS should
resign unilaterally if it lost Pengkalen Pasir. Under the election
laws amended after UMNO stalwart Dato' Shahrir Ahmad won as an
independent in the Johore Bahru parliamentary byelections in the
1980s, any one who resigns is automatically suspended from standing
for five years. There is no talk anymore of UMNO state assemblymen
resigning. PAS state assemblyman would resign if they are asked to
but UMNO state assemblymen would rather not. The UMNO elected
official makes it his life time occupation. He cannot afford to be
left on the sidelines. In UMNO it is the individual that counts, in
PAS the collective decision. The federal cabinet under the National
Front is so constructed that its members hold office for a lifetime.
The ministers and other political members of the government puts the
country in limbo so that they can survive. The prime minister dare
not sack them or reshuffle his cabinet for fear they will join his
enemies in the party. The byelections in Pengkalen Pasir is held not
so the people can elect their representative to the state assembly.
It believes that if the people of Malaysia accept its message, so
will the people of Pengkalen Pasir. The media, which it controls,
carry what National Front leaders from elsewhere are doing to ensure
UMNO's continued relevance in the state. But it is not true.
|
| 2005-11-23 | The prostitutes of globalisation
|
| 2005-11-19 | The rulers and the ruled go further apart by the day Education is one way of keeping the rulers separate from the ruled.
Conferences like APEC is another. I have a theory that officials go
for meetings by whatever name in exotic locations around the world
for two or three days so that they can have a holiday at public
expense. In Malaysia, civil servants from Johore Bahru fly to Pulau
Langkawi to discuss traffic along Sungei Johore, or some such. The
hotels get filled, the country or area gets the public approval, some
get their bank balances raised. But the result is a holiday, whatever
the reason for being in the exotic locale. But as the rulers act, the
ruled retaliate. So, as the years go by, the governments in power
pass laws to keep the ruled in check. But those who demonstrated in
favour of Dato' Seri Anwar Ibrahim in Dataran Merdeka, facing the
Selangor Court, got cold feet when the police retaliated in force. If
they had held their ground, and stayed put, the government could have
done nothing. But the demonstration broke up. Now the ordinary man
will not take part in any demonstration against the government, which
reacts with violent force at any such move. But the spark has been
lit. It may be years before it is lit again. But the question is
when, not if. There is no major dissidence for such a crowd to
gather. The government is fearful of that happening, and so arms
itself with powers to stop that. But with each policy against the
people, they organise themselves. The National Front is supposed to
get the races together, but its raison d'etre is to separate them.
Divide and rule is their practice, though unity in strength is the
motto. But the youngsters, from all races, cannot see the relevance
of the National Front, and unite, often in unemployment. More than
60,000 graduates from local universities cannot get jobs. That is a
grave danger for the National Front. Just 2,000 unemployed graduates
in Trengganu in 1990 helped PAS win the state. They have lost the
state since. But more than 2,000 unemployed graduated are with PAS in
the state. The National Front is formulating its policies so that the
opposition will benefit in the years ahead.
|
| 2005-11-18 | Why is Tun Ghafar's grave dug when he is still alive? THE GRAVE HAS BEEN DUG at the National Mosque, and those who went to
the National Mosque in Kuala Lumpur were told it is for the former
deputy prime minister, Tun Ghafar Baba, now in Pantai hospital where is
undergoing medical treatment. He is weak. He has been out of ICU for about
ten days, and looks poorly. He may not survive his stay in hospital, as Tun Razak
did not in a London hospital, but the officials have decided he would not return
from hospital alive. But the grave. ghoulishly, had to be dug three times because
the length of the grave each time not correct. The National Mosque has graves
for six who laboured for Malaysian independence. The former deputy prime minister,
Tun Ismail bin Abdul Rahman, was first, followed by the two prime ministers, Tun
Abdul Razak Hussein and Tun Hussein Onn. The man who should be there and the
first prime minister, Tengku Abdul Rahman, a member of the Kedah royal family,
decided before this death that he would be buried at the royal family
masouleum there. Another man, Dato' Sir Onn bin Jaffar, is not
counted by the officials, and died a lonely death because he was in
the opposition. His son, Tun Hussein Onn became prime minister, and
his grandson, Dato' Hiihamudin, sits in the present cabinet. But
Dato' Sir Onn, who was related to the Johore royal family, is buried
at the royal masouleum in Johore Bahru.
|
| 2005-11-01 | National Front parties were not formed to fight for Malaysian independence
|
| 2005-10-31 | Did Lee Kuan Yew want Singapore ejected from Malaysia?
|
| 2005-10-10 | The moral fibre has gone out of Malaysian politics
|
| 2005-10-04 | Historians and journalists are wrong when they are right
|
| 2005-09-24 | Why the Customs D-G would be allowed to retire gracefully I am interested in Tan Sri Halil Mutalib and his farewell party. I had gone to Klang last weekend and met a man whose life depended on the customs and excise department. He was told bluntly, by Tan Sri Halil and his deputies, that if he did not pay RM3,000 for the farewell party, he would face difficultes in his working life. He could bring along his wife or a friend for the price. That was later reduced to RM1,500. This bribery is prevalent in all government departments. In Putrajaya, for instance, one woman in each department is told she is in charge of cooking, and there are at least 20 women who give up their professional qualifications for the cooking every week. The government has since said there is provision for farewell parties for the chief, but this is for the whole country. But in the case of Tan Sri Haiil, it is RM250,000 for the whole country. His department spent RM160,000 for a golf game. Much of the money goes into the pockets of senior officials. At the English College (now the Makltab Sultan Abu Bakar) in Johore Bahru. it was common for us in the 1950s to collect funds for the school magazine from the school suppliers. Often, the cheques came in unasked. But the practice was common in those days. Today, funds are collected so that senior officials pocket the difference. This is common throughout the civil service. Many people cannot afford to go to the government departments for the bribe asked. You pay a lower amount at the bottom, and more as you go up the civil service ladder. Pak Lah cannot stop this by blaming his predecessor. He would be out of his job if he means what he says on corruption. His 'boys' are in it to the hilt. He would keep silent about his 'boys' for they are as guilty as Tan Sri Halil.
|
| 2005-09-14 | UMNO, the political party, is not UMNO, the nationalist movement. UMNO, or the UMNO Baru today, is not the nationalist political organisation that brought this country independence. UMNO that brought this country independence died in 1987, by court order, and in its place rose UMNO Baru. That UMNO Baru is formed is orchestrated by leaders of the old UMNO who led UMNO Baru. They were still in power, and they ordered the registrar of societies to declare Tengku Abdul Rahman's request for UMNO to be re-registered. He had filed the application several days earlier, but it was Tun Mahathir's UMNO Baru that was registered. As it happened, the founder of UMNO, Dato' Onn bin Jaffar, and the first UMNO president of Malaysia, and his son, the fourth president and third Malaysian prime minister, went to their graves without joining UMNO Baru. The flag of UMNO Baru is of different dimensions than of UMNO, but at first sight, they seem similar. In the Johore Bahru byelection, when UMNO Baru warlord, Dato' Shahrir Samad, stood as an independent but with strong support of the old UMNO adherents, the present Prime Minister, Pak Lah, told me at that time that when the two processions met at the crossroads before the nomination station in Johore Bahru, tears came to his eyes, for he saw two UMNO processsions where the two parties had met. It goes without saying that it was the independent who won. It is UMNO the political party that rules, and Dato' Shahir joined the party afterwards, and remains in Parliament as UMNO Baru MP. The question asked by diplomats and even UMNO bigwigs and members is whether Pak Lah would be challenged. I think he would, Dato' Shahrir Samad being the last minute candidate if the other warlords decide not to. Pak Lah is UMNO Baru president held hostage by UMNO warlords, which is why he has not sacked from his cabinet the two warlords - Dato' Isa Samad, found guilty of money politics; and Datin (or rather as she would prefer to be called, Dato') Rafidah, who was guilty of giving her son-in-law a monthly wage of about Rm 1.5 million by giving him sufficient APs. (It is said, and not in jest, that she should be known as Rafidah AP Aziz). But both will not resign from the cabinet and neither will they be sacked. They hold enormous power in their areas of strength, Isa in the Linggi area and possibly Malacca; and Datin Rafidah, in the Kuala Kangsar area that she is MP of. Fearing that either or both would go to those opposed to Pak Lah in UMNO is why they both remain in the cabinet.
|
<< Previous | 1 2 3 4 5 | Next >>
| |
 |
|
|
|
|
| |
This archive was created as a tribute to the late veteran
journalist MGG Pillai. We believed his writings are useful to develop a critical
thinking analysis.
By the way, the original mggpillai.com web site (2001-2006) was actually created
by one of us.
|
|